Logo Image
|Articles|June 25, 2012

Teva Wins Patent-infringement Lawsuit Protecting Copaxone

US court ruled in favor of Teva in its patent-infringement lawsuit against Momenta and Mylan's generic versions of Teva's Copaxone.

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York found in favor of Teva Pharmaceuticals in the company’s patent-infringement lawsuit against Momenta Pharmaceuticals/Sandoz and Mylan Laboratories/Natco Pharmaceuticals regarding Teva’s relapsing-remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) product, Copaxone, the company said in a June 23, 2012 press release.  The suit included infringement of multiple patents covering the chemical composition of Copaxone, methods of using the product, and processes for manufacturing the product.  The defendants had claimed that the patents were invalid and unenforceable, but the judge rejected this claim and ruled that the generic versions of Copaxone infringe upon Teva’s patents. This ruling should prevent FDA approval of generic versions in the US at least until the Orange Book patents expire on May 24, 2012. Teva believes the decision will further prevent the sale of generics until the process patent expires on September 1, 2015.

Mylan expressed its disappointment in the decision.  “While we have not yet had the opportunity to review the Court's opinion, we fully intend to evaluate our options for an appeal once the Court's full opinion becomes available,” stated Heather Bresch, CEO of Mylan, in a June 25, 2012 press release.   Mylan’s earnings guidance for 2012 and earnings targets for 2013 remain unchanged because they were not reliant on the launch of a generic Copaxone, Bresch added.  In 2008, Mylan had signed an agreement to license and supply India’s Natco Pharma’s glatiramer acetate prefilled syringes, a generic version of Copaxone.

Momenta, which had partnered with Sandoz, a division of Novartis, also stated its intention to appeal the decision. "We are disappointed that the court determined that Teva's patents were valid and infringed, and we look forward to reading the full opinion to understand its reasoning," commented Craig Wheeler, president and chief executive officer of Momenta in a June 22, 2012 press release.  "We remain confident in our legal position and we intend to appeal."

Related to this article

View more
The BioPharm Brief: A Bispecific Approval in Head and Neck Cancer, TCR Bispecifics Head to the Clinic, and a New Antibody Target in Essential Thrombocythemia
The BioPharm Brief: A Bispecific Approval in Head and Neck Cancer, TCR Bispecifics Head to the Clinic, and a New Antibody Target in Essential Thrombocythemia
FDA grants accelerated approval to Johnson & Johnson’s subcutaneous EGFR/MET bispecific Rybrevant Faspro for previously treated head and neck squamous cell carcinoma, T-Therapeutics raises a $133 million Series B to take TCR-CD3 bispecifics into clinical trials, and Alethio Therapeutics raises a $90 million Series A to advance its first-in-class G6B antibody for essential thrombocythemia.
Read more
The BioPharm Brief: Ivonescimab Priority Review in China, Stargardt Gene Therapy Moves Toward Phase 3, and Longer Dosing Intervals for an IBD Bispecific
The BioPharm Brief: Ivonescimab Priority Review in China, Stargardt Gene Therapy Moves Toward Phase 3, and Longer Dosing Intervals for an IBD Bispecific
China’s NMPA grants priority review to Akeso’s PD-1/VEGF bispecific ivonescimab with chemotherapy for first-line biliary tract cancer, VeonGen Therapeutics aligns with FDA on a phase 3 design for its dual-AAV Stargardt gene therapy VG801, and Caldera Therapeutics’ IL-23p19×TL1A bispecific CLD-423 shows a half-life of more than 40 days in a phase 1a trial.
Read more