Development of a Novel Rolling-Tube Cell Culture Platform and Demonstration of System Feasibility - A new rolling-tube system balances scale-up accuracy and thoroughput. - BioPharm International


Development of a Novel Rolling-Tube Cell Culture Platform and Demonstration of System Feasibility
A new rolling-tube system balances scale-up accuracy and thoroughput.

BioPharm International
Volume 23, Issue 8

Rolling tubes and T-flasks demonstrated comparable culture performance and metabolite profiles, as well as product potencies (Figures 1, 2, and 3). In comparison, 6-well plates demonstrated inferior growth to either T75 flasks or 50-mL rolling tubes. Cell density (Figure 1) reached a maximum of ~0.7 x 106 vc/mL compared with ~2.0 x 106 vc/mL for the other two platforms. Glutamine consumption (Figure 2a) was lower, although no significant difference in glucose consumption was observed (Figure 2c). Lactate levels increased (Figure 2d) possibly because of less efficient gas transfer in the 6-well platform, causing a shift toward anaerobic metabolism. The significant increase in osmolality over time (Figure 2h) was notable. This phenomenon was investigated using 6-well plates with uninoculated media.

Evaporation was the apparent reason for the significant rise in osmolality and in glutamine and glucose metabolites in the 6-well plate platform (data not shown). Total production of the desired protein (Figure 3a) also was much lower in 6-well plates than in the other platforms, though per cell specific productivity (Figure 3b) was ~40% greater. This could have resulted from the much lower viable cell densities (Figure 1a) in the 6-well plate platform caused by the higher osmolality resulting from evaporation or a shift in metabolism toward production (rather than growth) because of osmotic stress.4

Figure 4. Amino acid analysis of small scale versus production-scale spent media. The percent change in levels of different amino acids in spent media relative to the starting fresh media is shown for production scale runs and for representative screening scale runs (T-flask).
The performance of the small-scale systems also was representative of commercial production on the basis of spent media analysis performed on cultures from both scales using the same cell line and media. It should be noted that seeding density and passage schedule have been designed to emulate cell-specific perfusion rate in production bioreactors. In Figure 4, the amino acid profile of small scale is compared to production-scale culture. The similarity in the profile (i.e., in the extent of consumption, or for some amino acids, the extent of production) between the scales strongly suggests that the optimized small-scale systems are able to predict the performance in bioreactors in applications such as media or clone screening.


In this study, we assessed the performance of the rolling tube platform compared to the T-75 flask and the 6-well plate platforms. Although T-flasks recently have replaced the large roller bottles in many laboratory-scale applications on the basis of culture performance (internal data, not shown), they also have major drawbacks including throughput and ease of operation. Other small-scale systems used in a variety of screening applications, such as micro-bioreactors, are not covered here because they have major drawbacks, most notably cost.5 This study demonstrates that the rolling-tube system is a platform of choice for development projects because it performs similarly to the T-flask (and the roller bottle, data not shown) but is much more user friendly and has higher throughput. Evaporation minimization, pH control, and gas transfer rates are superior in the rolling tube system as a result of the mixing through rolling motion where media is in greater contact with the vessel surface and because of the geometry of the tubes that contain vented caps.

On the other hand, the 6-well plate platform demonstrated inferior performance resulting from evaporation and gas transfer problems. Data including metabolite analysis, cell growth rate, viability, specific productivity, and product titer and potency show the performance of rolling tubes is comparable to the T-flask and superior to 6-well plates. The rolling tubes also demonstrated robust and consistent performance at a broad range of working volumes. This allows for the designing of fill volumes tailored to the volumes and frequency required for sampling (e.g., for metabolites and titer determination) in a given experimental and screening design. Seeding density and passage schedule have been optimized to emulate perfusion reactor conditions.

Samples submitted to spent media analysis (e.g., amino acids, Figure 4) demonstrated a similar profile to that of production samples, indicating scalability and the ability to predict performance in production bioreactors. The platform is ideal for suspension-adapted cell lines because the cell tested did not adhere to the tube's surface, and because passaging and harvest is greatly facilitated by the possibility of using the growth vessels (i.e., the 50-mL tube) as the harvest vessel by centrifugation, eliminating volume transfer steps. This significantly reduces labor handling and the risk of contamination, and increases efficiency. Ergonomics and handling also are made easier by the ability to line up tubes in a relatively small footprint inside a biological hood; volume culture transfer is facilitated by the wide opening of the tubes.

Additional benefits of the rolling-tube system include: low material and operation costs (for purchase of the disposable tubes and rolling device), low media volume usage, and the ability to run up to 16 tubes per platform simultaneously; this number can be increased by using additional stackable platforms. The platforms can be placed on a shelf inside a humidified temperature controlled CO2 incubator. The platform withstands continuous operation in the incubator's environment. Given the advantages of the rolling-tube system in performance and handling, it is a preferred platform for a variety of cell culture applications.


The rolling-tube platform presents an ideal balance between predictability of performance at production scale, throughput, robustness, and ease of use, while also providing sufficient sample volumes for product and analytical testing. Its gentle agitation with mixing through rolling also emulates the cumbersome but traditional roller bottle "small-scale" system. We currently use the rolling-tube platform in cell line selection and process development projects such as media screening using design of experiment approaches.

Yuval Shimoni is principal engineer, Carmen Chin is a senior associate process engineer II, Teng Liu is a laboratory technician, Veronica Hernandez-Rodriguez is a laboratory assistant, Peter Kramer is director, and Jin Wang is manager, all in manufacturing sciences, product supply biotech at Bayer HealthCare, Berkeley, CA, 510.705.5775,
Volker Moehrle is a senior scientist at Bayer Technology Services, Leverkusen, Germany.


1. Eibl R, Kaiser S, Lombriser R, Eibl D. Disposable bioreactors: the current state-of-the-art and recommended applications in biotechnology. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol. 2010;86:41–9.

2. De Jesus MJ, Girard P, Bourgeois M, Baumgartner G, Jacko B, Amstutz H, Wurm FM. TubeSpin satellites: A fast track approach for process development with animal cells using shaking technology. Biochem Engin J. 2004;17:217–23.

3. Jordan M, Jenkins N. Tools for high-throughput medium and process optimization. Methods in Biotechnology: methods and protocols, 2nd Ed. Portner R (Editor) 2007;24:193–202.

4. Yi X, Sun X, Zhang Y. Effects of osmotic pressure on recombinant BHK cell growth and von willebrand factor (vWF) expression. Proc Biochem. 2004;39:1817–23.

5. Amanullah A, Otero JM, Mikola M, Hsu A, Zhang J, Aunins J, Schreyer HB, Hope J, Russo P. Novel micro-bioreactor high throughput technology for cell culture process development: reproducibility and scalability assessment of fed-batch CHO cultures. Biotechnol Bioeng. 2010;106:57–67.

blog comments powered by Disqus



Mallinckrodt to Acquire Questcor Pharmaceuticals
April 16, 2014
EMA Warns of Falsified Herceptin Vials
April 16, 2014
PhRMA Report Reveals Growth Trajectories and Policy Factors Affecting Biopharmaceutical Growth
April 11, 2014
Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research Relocates
April 11, 2014
American CryoStem and Rutgers University File Joint Patent on Stem Cell Platform
April 11, 2014
Author Guidelines
Source: BioPharm International,
Click here