Through an illustrative case study, this article demonstrated how to use process simulation tools to assist in the evaluation
of process alternatives. Two options for buffer preparation and holding activities of a typical MAb process were analyzed
from an economic perspective. The first used single-use buffer preparation and storage bags, whereas the second used traditional
stainless-steel preparation and holding tanks. The single-use system proved to be more advantageous for smaller scales, whereas
the stainless-steel option becomes more economical as the production scale increases. The evaluation results are specific
to the MAb process analyzed. Additional process options and alternative technologies can be readily evaluated and compared
using such tools.
Victor Papavasileiou is a senior applications engineer, Charles Siletti, PhD, is director of scheduling and planning applications, and Demetri Petrides, PhD, is president, all at Intelligen, Inc., Scotch Plains, NJ, 908.654.0088, email@example.com
1. Aranha, H. Disposable systems. One more manufacturing option. BioProcess Int. 2004; Oct Suppl.
2. Sinclair A. Disposable bioreactors: the next generation. BioPharm Int. 2008;21(4):38–40.
3. Martin L, Bartow M, Schaidle B, Tuttle G, Sandstrom C. Managing large volume, single use disposables in biopharmaceutical
manufacturing. In: Langer ES, editor. Advances in large-scale biopharmaceutical manufacturing and scale-up production. Virginia:
ASM Press; 2007.
4. Petrides DP, Koulouris A, Lagonikos PT. The role of process simulation in pharmaceutical process development and product
commercialization. Pharma Eng. 2002;Jan/Feb.
5. Thomas CJ. A design approach to biotech process simulations. BioProcess Int. 2003;10:2–9.
6. Petrides DP, Siletti CA. The role of process simulation and scheduling tools in the development and manufacturing of biopharmaceuticals.
In: Ingalls RG, Rossetti MD, Smith JS, Peters BA, editors. Proceedings of the 2004 winter simulation conference. 2004. p.
7. Hwang F. Batch pharmaceutical process design and simulation. Pharm Eng. 1997;Jan/Feb:28–43.
8. Harrison RG, Todd P, Rudge SR, Petrides DP. Bioseparations science and engineering. Oxford University Press; 2003. p. 319–372.
9. Heinzle E, Biwer AP, Cooney CL. Development of sustainable bioprocesses. John Wiley & Sons; 2006.
10. Achilleos EC, Calandranis JC, Petrides DP. Quantifying the impact of uncertain parameters in the batch manufacturing of
active pharmaceutical ingredients. Pharm Eng. 2006;Jul/Aug:34–40.