Scaling Down of Biopharmaceutical Unit Operations — Part 2: Chromatography and Filtration - Constraints associated with equipment can make scale-down a challenging exercise. - BioPharm


Scaling Down of Biopharmaceutical Unit Operations — Part 2: Chromatography and Filtration
Constraints associated with equipment can make scale-down a challenging exercise.

BioPharm International

Controlling temperature at small scale to mimic that of cold rooms or cold-boxes can be a challenge. The use of water baths with column jacketing can provide precise temperature control, but the tubing leading up to the column can frequently act as a mini heat exchanger, making it difficult to control the actual inlet temperature. Using heat exchangers on the inlet tubing and column jacketing may be necessary for accurate, consistent, and precise temperature control.

Figure 1. Chromatographic Profiles of Small- and Large-scale Columns. Raw material is a proprietary aqueous solution that has undergone one step of preliminary purification. The small column (green data) is 1.6 cm dia by 12 cm. The large column (black data) is 63 cm dia by 12 cm.
Operational Equivalence The general approach towards qualification of a scale-down model is to run all operational parameters (inputs) at the center of the operating range used at large scale (clinical or commercial manufacturing). The performance parameters (outputs) such as step yields, pool purity, impurity clearance, elution volume and retention time should be similar across scales. Some of the significant operational parameters include:
  • Column loading (g protein/L resin) should be the same at both scales. In size-exclusion chromatography, the loading should be based on a volume percentage of the column bed volume.
  • Gradient lengths (in number of column volumes) and slopes (increase in percent limit buffer per unit time, or similar measurement) should be the same for all steps of a chromatography procedure such as equilibration, wash, and elution.
  • Temperature, pH, and conductivity should be identical for all buffers and feed streams. Differences in temperature across scales can lead to significant changes in con- ductivity of some buffers that may impact step performance.
  • Bed height of the chromatography column and the linear flow velocity are generally kept constant across scales. The ICH guideline on viral safety states that the validity of the scaling down should be demonstrated, and that column bed height should be shown to be representative of commercial scale manufacturing.1 If this is not possible and the bed height is different at small scale, the linear flow velocity should be adjusted appropriately to keep the residence time constant.2
  • Pooling criteria should be the same as in manufacturing. They can be online (conductivity or absorbance) or offline (gels or HPLC). In our experience, if the pooling criteria are UV-based, it is a good practice to ensure that the UV detectors of the small-scale systems correlate well with those in the large-scale system. UV detectors may be inaccurate or non-linear over the optical density (O.D.) ranges required. If the absorbance range is non-linear at 280 nm, it may be prudent to measure the on-line O.D. at 300 nm or some other wavelength that has a lower extinction coefficient.

Model Qualification Pre-determine the acceptance criteria prior to the scale-down runs. These can be based on a statistical comparison of the small-scale data against the full-scale data using a t-test, tolerance intervals, or other statistical tests. Alternatively, it may be demonstrated that the small-scale data are within the full-scale historical range. The approach taken may depend on the inherent variability of the assays used to determine quality attributes or the amount of large-scale data available. Sometimes there may be no large-scale data available at this stage of the project and the qualification of the small-scale model may have to be done retrospectively after data from large scale are available. It is a good practice to perform several small-scale runs (at least three), to better understand the inherent variability of the process, particularly when there are limited amounts of large-scale data available for comparison.

blog comments powered by Disqus



EMA Warns of Falsified Herceptin Vials
April 16, 2014
Mallinckrodt to Acquire Questcor Pharmaceuticals
April 16, 2014
American CryoStem and Rutgers University File Joint Patent on Stem Cell Platform
April 11, 2014
Center for Biologics Evaluation and Research Relocates
April 11, 2014
PhRMA Report Reveals Growth Trajectories and Policy Factors Affecting Biopharmaceutical Growth
April 11, 2014
Author Guidelines
Source: BioPharm International,
Click here