Modeling of Biopharmaceutical Processes. Part 2: Process Chromatography Unit Operation - How to apply the latest thinking in process modeling to your process using a Quality by Design approach. - BioP


Modeling of Biopharmaceutical Processes. Part 2: Process Chromatography Unit Operation
How to apply the latest thinking in process modeling to your process using a Quality by Design approach.

BioPharm International
Volume 21, Issue 8


Process modeling can be a useful tool to aid in process development, process optimization, and process scale-up. When modeling a chromatography process, one must first select the appropriate models that describe the mass transfer and adsorption that occurs within the porous adsorbent. The theoretical understanding of chromatographic behavior can augment available experimental data and aid in the design of specific experiments to develop a more complete understanding of the behavior of a unit operation.

Avecia Biologics Limited
Biotech unit operations, including process chromatography, are complex because of the large number of factors that affect process performance. A typical process chromatography step has 50–100 operating parameters that can impact its performance. In addition, a similar number of raw materials are used during the process step. It is not feasible to evaluate the effect of all of these variables on step performance. The current practice is to use risk analysis to identify process parameters that need to be examined during process characterization with the extent of process modeling limited to use of linear statistical models.1–7

Anurag Rathore
An example of such statistical modeling has been published before in this series.5 The case study involved the design of a process analytical technology-based control scheme for a cation-exchange chromatography step. A design of experiments (DoE) study consisting of 17 experiments was conducted with purity of the load material, start point of pooling (start collect), and end point of pooling (stop collect) as variables. Pool purity and step yield were monitored for each experiment. The results were analyzed using statistical software and are presented in Figure 1. It is seen that load purity and stop collect have a significant impact, where as start collect does not have a significant impact on pool purity. This model was then used to calculate the pool purity for all the experiments that were performed. Figure 2 illustrates a comparison of the pool purities calculated using the statistical model and the actual pool purity as measured by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (RP HPLC). It is seen that the two numbers correlate very well and support feasibility of this scheme. While this example highlights the usefulness of an empirical model, there are significant limitations of this approach. First, because the model is not based on fundamental principles that govern the unit operation, its predictions are limited to the ranges of data for process parameters that the model is based on, e.g., load impurity of 1.8–5.8% for the case study illustrated in Figure 1. Second, just like any other modeling approach, the underlying assumptions have to hold true for the model to be accurate.

Figure 1.Statistical analysis of data from chromatography experiments
If possible, it is always preferable to create a process model based on fundamental principles. Such a process model can be used as a tool for optimization, scale-up, and manufacturing support. This article is the thirteenth in the Elements of Biopharmaceutical Production series and focuses on process modeling tools that can be useful in capturing the process understanding. We review some of the significant and recent contributions in the area of process modeling of process chromatography along with examples from existing biotech processes.1–5

blog comments powered by Disqus



Suppliers Seek to Boost Single-Use Technology
August 21, 2014
Bristol-Myers Squibb and Celgene Collaborate on Immunotherapy and Chemotherapy Combination Regimen
August 20, 2014
USP Center in Ghana Receives International Lab Accreditation
August 15, 2014
USP Awards Analytical Research
August 15, 2014
FDA Warns about Fraudulent Ebola Treatments
August 15, 2014
Author Guidelines
Source: BioPharm International,
Click here